Oil – black, foul-smelling, polluting. Not in my backyard!
In a perfect world, I would agree with the environmental lobby’s assessment of our dependence on “black gold”. But as Winston Churchill observed about democracy, it may be an absolutely awful system, but it’s better than the alternative. For better or worse, we are not moving away from oil any time soon. Ask yourself – do you see any industrial economy going oil-free in the next 12 months? Three years? Five years? Ten years? Twenty five years? If you’re honest, the answer is no. Oil is here to stay. Not just to run our cars, but to produce the plastic we can’t live without. (Try to imagine a world without plastic – I bet you can’t.)
Sure, we may design more fuel efficient vehicles and alternatives to plastics. That’s a good thing. But we will probably never wean ourselves completely off the stuff. It’s just too darn useful.
If you accept the argument that oil production is not going away, that leaves us with a real world problem. How do we address the obvious downsides of oil production in the most ethical way possible? Is there such a thing as ethical oil?
Ezra Levant, in his new book Ethical Oil, the Case for Canada’s Oilsands makes a compelling argument that there is such as thing as ethical oil. Perhaps not in the white and black world of environmental fantasy, but in the real world where hard choices have to be made. The Canadian oil sands have received a lot of bad press. Ducks died in tailings ponds. Water may be polluted. Oil sands are yucky! But Mr. Levant points out that the alternative to oil produced in Canada is not the opposite of bad – it’s worse.
He looks at four key factors that are dear to every liberal’s heart: the environment, wages, human rights and democratic freedoms. I get all warm and fuzzy just thinking about them. He then compares Canada’s record on these issues to the other major sources of oil production such as Saudi Arabia, Nigeria, the Sudan and Venezuela. Just writing the names of these countries quickly brings into focus the stark contrast with Canada. Saudi Arabia uses its oil revenues to export a virulent form of Islamic fundamentalism around the world. Nigeria has more than 2000 oil spills the size of the Exxon Valdez that will never be cleaned up because the infrastructure and the rule of law do not exists there. The Sudan hits the news by killing 300,000 Rawandans. Venezuela is run by a socialist dictator.
Canada, by comparison, has strong environmental legislation on the books and the power to enforce that legislation. Our country is known around the world for its tolerance and support of human rights. We practically invented “peacekeeping”. We live in a functioning democracy where voting is not a life-threatening exercise.
Sure there is room for improvement. We’re not perfect – but we’re a hell of a lot better than the alternative. Canadian oil is ethical oil, despite the attempts of a misguided media to portray it otherwise. Several large corporations in the U.S. have decided they will not buy oil produced in the Canadian oil sands. This is simply ill-informed. If they don’t buy Canadian oil, their only remaining source is from unethical, despotic tyrants who fund terror against us or their own people.
Oil is dirty. No one likes it. But unless you plan on living in a yurt and using horses for transport, you should man up and accept your part in this problem. If our oil production is polluting, we can find a better way. In fact, the oil sands have reduced their carbon footprint by 38% over the past 20 years. Human rights are important to all Canadians, and supported by our legislation and our traditions. Those other guys? – Not so much! Wages? Fort McMurray, the centre of oil sands production in Canada, has the highest per capital income in all of Canada. Even with our dismal record with our native populations, more than 2000 aboriginals are directly employed by the oil sands with millions of dollars going into native owned businesses.
Ethical decisions don’t come much simpler than this.
Optimal Simplicity for the Impatient
- Canadian oil sands are the most ethical source of oil on the planet.
- Before you get on your environment hobby horse, get real instead.
- Conservative loudmouths sometimes speak the truth about the emperor’s clothes.







